We only have like two or three active RPs right now so dividing everything seems like overkill. Those that come along and RP with short hand or whatever won't even bother to make the distinction, so there's no need to make it any more confusing than necessary. Why not just use the same forum and have people mark the RPs with something like *PRIVATE* or *READ GUIDELINES FIRST* like always.
... That way every RP will be forced to use asterisks in one way or another.
If it ever got to the point where we had to divide the forums to reduce clutter... that'd be a day worth celebrating. It just doesn't seem like the right time. But if it allows asterisks in some form, then by all means.
Edit: I'd make the two Tournament and Factions forums invisible. Maybe move Spotlight Theatre up past the Reviews section... It's so low. And hey, why not merge it with Auditorium. But I'm getting off-topic.
Bookmarks