They wanted me to go to REHAB.

**loaf** · 07-25-2011, 02:11 AM

In this thread: Opinions.

**Polk** · 07-25-2011, 02:39 AM

Snobby Music Discussion: The Thread (oh yeah guys by the way Amy Winehouse is dead)

On Topic: Not too familiar with her music, I think she did a cover of Monkey Man that was pretty good? I may be wrong. Thoughts and prayers to her friends and family, but I think I'll somehow be able to go on with my life.

**Rocky** · 07-25-2011, 02:43 AM

since its almost 5am and I'm really tired atm, I'll just say that its cool for people to like what they want to like, but I see a lot of people bashing widely acclaimed artists like Hendrix because it's the "hipster" thing to do. (not liking famous bands/musicians, I mean). I'm not saying you're doing it for that specific reason Maridia, but I just find that a bold opinion to have. It's w/e though, end result is drugs are bad and that Amy Winehouse will never have a Last Friday Night again.

**nix** · 07-25-2011, 03:45 AM

Originally Posted by Maridia

Hendrix is overated, yep I said it. I'm not saying he didn't change the way guitar was looked at, that's the one thing I'll give him. But his songs themselves aren't that great. Again when you can take a handful of ones off of itunes and that's it, it doesn't make you a legend. It's the mystique of death people feed into with so many old rock stars.

Joplin sounds like a bad Robert Plant impersonator, without the lyrical talent.. Morrison is a guy people call a "poet" which is pretentious for someone who was built up, especially when you can sum up the doors catalogue in a greatest hits cd.

Saying you hate rap is fine. But if you really look at rap or rock they can be just as 2 dimensional. Someone's blazing and feeling good with their woman, and the others are drinking 40's gang bangin'. So it's just as easy to throw stones at each.

If you want an amazing album listen to something like Quadrophenia, by The Who. Written 95% by one person, who did the synth, guitar, lyrics, and general album concept. There's plenty of good rock and rap out there, but I think you're taking it too personally my dislike for some bands/musicians that you feel are way above others. The whole point of music is a personal value. So what if I don't like a group. It becomes a sports debate of x is better than z. Then someone says pfffft and it goes on forever. Like what you will but just cause I don't think we need to bow down to every band who's name I've heard on the classic rock station doesn't make my taste bad. Just means I'm not one track minded.

This post is alot better, i commend you for a good response.

I wasnt attacking your dislike towards them, just that you called them talentless.

Infact im with you on artists getting too much love, i agree that alot in the 27 club are way over rated.

But they all had talent and influenced millions

**Xanatos** · 07-25-2011, 04:08 AM

My sister is huge fan of her's, I on the other hand can't stand her music, this was inevitable I guess, with her lifestyle and all. All that's left to be said is rest in peace Amy.

**nickness89** · 07-25-2011, 05:09 AM

Originally Posted by Rocky

I really liked her california girls song too

Sorry, I just had to add, Katy Perry sings California Girls.

@che - Come on now, that's Sarah Silverman in the picture ... have you been high again?

I agree that the massacre in Norway was disgusting and a lot more tragic than Amy's death, but death is death either way, and neither deserve more attention than the other.

**loaf** · 07-25-2011, 05:12 AM

Nick. I've lost all hope in you. For those replies right there.

BTW I like how Pamela Anderson is in that video with Justin Timberlake in your sig.

**nickness89** · 07-25-2011, 05:25 AM

Originally Posted by Loaf

Nick. I've lost all hope in you. For those replies right there.

BTW I like how Pamela Anderson is in that video with Justin Timberlake in your sig.

That's Lady Gaga!!

Oh god, they were all jokes weren't they, even the things I replied on? Eughh ... fml big time

**seanb** · 07-25-2011, 06:00 AM

R.I.P Amy

Elton john is going to sing a rendition of 'Candle under a spoon' at the funeral.

xxx <3 xxx

**Unknown Entity** · 07-25-2011, 08:19 AM

I'm a little annoyed by a lot of the jokes and comments my friends have made about her death, especially the ones along the lines of "stupid slag deserved to die!" To me, it just shows that person's value of human life, and it's quite sickening that anyone would think anyone deserves to die.

Going by their logic, it's good to know that if I ever hit a low point in my life, and died as a result of it, that I'd deserve it; even better to know that my friends who have made crazy lifestyle choices deserve to die too. ¬¬

As for her music, I liked it. She had a pretty good "jazzy" voice, and I liked that. She had a lot of talent, and it's sad that that talent is gone because of her bad decisions. She could have done well/better with herself if she'd cleaned her act up, and could have led a happy life. That's not to say not being clean was what made her unhappy or happy, but... yeah.

**Lily** · 07-25-2011, 10:25 AM

i can't say im arsed about her one way or the other, afew of her tracks are listen to able, never really pay attention to what was going on in her life, it was just the same old winehouse is pissed

FB has exploded. i dont see how people can be so shocked about a junkie dying or finding it sad and getting offended when people just dont give a shit

sure its a shame someone died, but its no one i know or care about so im not arsed

apparently her music is flying back up the charts/album charts. I dont get that either...

another one of those that will end up more famous in death, than she was alive no doubt.

**seanb** · 07-25-2011, 10:32 AM

A wise man called John Lennon once said 'Everybody loves you when your six feet under'
He was right. And became an example of what he said, because he has many wannabe fans that idolize his tragic death instead of idolizing his life/music.

So does Michael Jackson, so does Piccasso! and now Amy Winehouse, she is gaining new fans as we speak.

**Pete** · 07-26-2011, 01:39 PM

I have to say that I don't give a shit. She was a stupid crackhead junkie, who had some real talent. She cashed that talent in and bought more drugs and got herself in with the wrong crowds. You can't really be surprised, and from the looks of it, she really didn't try to fix herself up. The only difference between her and any other junkie was that someone had discovered her and she made lots of money because she had a voice.