Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3
Results 61 to 90 of 137

Thread: God/Religion. Why?

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Registered User God/Religion. Why? sayian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    north west ark
    Age
    41
    Posts
    203
    Blog Entries
    1

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Quote Originally Posted by RamesesII View Post
    I have had a question digging in the back of my head since the day I mutilated my old work ute into a tree at 100km/h.

    How do you differentiate between a god and fate or luck.

    I myself believe that it was luck that I was able to steer the vehicle as well as I did considering the fact that I think I closed my eyes just before I hit it.

    But other people would take it that god had saved them that day.

    Interesting to know that my great grandmother on my wifes side of the family especially blessed our family in her prayers that night/morning.

    Taking this into to account I still don't believe in a god and I don't have a religious faith. When you think about it I take it to be a naive approach to life and I don't mean any disrespect by this comment, but when you look at ancient history and see what the people of old believed in and that each country and race of people had many and different gods because the were naive they had nothing else to believe in they had no way of explaining how things happened.
    What I believe was that religion and gods were created to rally people to follow one person for example many leadership figures also claimed to be prophets and or channels of gods.



    On another note
    Having faith in a religion or being religious doesn't provide that person good moral values, the person themselves is the only person that has control over that, religion may teach their values and morals but it is within the person to execute those teachings. Not only that but it also comes down to how a person was raised by their parents, 100% of how we raise our children is embedded into our brains on how we were raised by our parents.
    We are not born with the ability to be perfect parents as soon as we come out of the womb.
    So it is up to the individual to either pass the moral values that they were taught or to correct what their parents have instilled upon them as long as you can pull yourself up on these things.




    Sure u can look the words "luck" or "fate" in the dictionary but God is in our essence. The difference is u don't need to look God up or do research. We as human have faults which includes mistranslation of communication through time.. but the ONLY thing GOD wrote Himself and would not entrust in man to document on is the Ten Commandments. and all 10 of them are in us.

    Yea, argue about the bible and fight over what the bible translates into or that it contradicts itself all you want because its not entirely about the bible. Argue about religion this or that all you want because its not about religion. Sound very smart and well thought out if u can, but u cant argue what God wrote Himself in our essence.. No1 cheats on their spouse without knowing they're sinning. No1 commits murder without knowing they're sinning. No1 uses Gods name in vein without feeling any amount of fear. Give me an example of a perfect lie.. u cant.. No1 steals without trying to be sneaky.. and so on.

    We all know whats wrong, and just as well, we all know whats right... <- you're not gonna find that in the dictionary and u don't even need a bible to know that.

    personally, i don't believe there's a single man on earth who genuinely doesn't believe in God. its impossible. they just embrace their sins a little too much and try to come up with excuses to justify their illegitimate denial of believing in Gods existence to make themselves feel less bad about sinning. they'll be trying until they're dead because its in our essence to know and feel bad for disobeying..

    So for the ones who act like they don't know... Y'all know! For every argument we can come up with, point you prove, or religion you dont support or understand... We dont need any of that.. Gods word is in us already, and He wants us to apply it.
    Last edited by sayian; 02-27-2012 at 07:35 AM.

  2. #2
    attempting to bribe the Mayor of Lambeth God/Religion. Why? Xanatos's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Bosnia and Herzegovina
    Age
    36
    Posts
    2,611

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    I don't really like to talk about religion, it never ends well... nevertheless, I'll share a word or two this time.

    I was raised as a Roman Catholic. I had my doubts, for quite some time I refused to believe there's such thing as higher power, and even if God does exist, he gave up on us long time ago. I do however believe in higher power, a God if you will, though I lost my faith in church. Church is full of hypocrites and people who judge others, a guy siting on a gold chair surrounded by pure gold statues is telling me I should be humble and help others. I don't know about other places, but here church asks way too much, and in return does bare minimum if anything to help those who genuinely need help.

    Why do I believe in God? It's kinda hard to explain. This world, the entire universe is just way to beautiful and complex to pop out of nothing, and I feel better and secure believing there's more to it than meets the eye.

    To each it's own I say, thus I condemn those who force their religion on others, and those who use religion the way they see fit, for instance to make profit, like church does nowdays.

    Sig and Avy made by Unknown Entity

  3. #3
    Registered User God/Religion. Why? Halie's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    :)
    Posts
    2,455
    Blog Entries
    13

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Quote Originally Posted by Xanatos View Post
    I don't really like to talk about religion, it never ends well... nevertheless, I'll share a word or two this time.

    I was raised as a Roman Catholic. I had my doubts, for quite some time I refused to believe there's such thing as higher power, and even if God does exist, he gave up on us long time ago. I do however believe in higher power, a God if you will, though I lost my faith in church. Church is full of hypocrites and people who judge others, a guy siting on a gold chair surrounded by pure gold statues is telling me I should be humble and help others. I don't know about other places, but here church asks way too much, and in return does bare minimum if anything to help those who genuinely need help.

    Why do I believe in God? It's kinda hard to explain. This world, the entire universe is just way to beautiful and complex to pop out of nothing, and I feel better and secure believing there's more to it than meets the eye.

    To each it's own I say, thus I condemn those who force their religion on others, and those who use religion the way they see fit, for instance to make profit, like church does nowdays.
    I have a very similar view to you, I don't actually follow a religion and I don't believe in a particular God but I do feel like there's something bigger out there that we just don't know about and probably never will know about because like you said, the world is extremely complex and it had to come from somewhere/something.

    I don't like religion because I personally feel like it does more harm than good, but at the same time I understand that it really does help people to have religious faith. However there are so many hypocritical people out there who take it too far and become blinded by religion. I'm not saying all religious people are blind, but I've come across so many who blindly hate others because their supposed God has told them to, and yet they try to preach peace and want to make the world a better place?

    The way I see it is that I'd prefer to live my life in the now, so even if there is a God I'd still like to live my life the way I want to, because it is extremely unlikely that proof of Good will present itself in my lifetime so I may as well embrace my life and live it how I want to. I don't believe in heaven or hell, so it doesn't bother me if I commit "sins". Say I'm an extremely nice person who does many, many good things and helps people but has sex before marriage, does that mean I deserve to be shunned and deserve to go to hell? I don't think so... yet there are people who would argue that I do deserve to.

    I normally don't like to talk in threads like this because some people get really touchy and mean but I keep getting drawn to it so why not.

  4. #4

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Quote Originally Posted by sayian View Post

    Yea, argue about the bible and fight over what the bible translates into or that it contradicts itself all you want because its not entirely about the bible. Argue about religion this or that all you want because its not about religion. Sound very smart and well thought out if u can, but u cant argue what God wrote Himself in our essence.. No1 cheats on their spouse without knowing they're sinning. No1 commits murder without knowing they're sinning. No1 uses Gods name in vein without feeling any amount of fear. Give me an example of a perfect lie.. u cant.. No1 steals without trying to be sneaky.. and so on.

    We all know whats wrong, and just as well, we all know whats right... <- you're not gonna find that in the dictionary and u don't even need a bible to know that.

    personally, i don't believe there's a single man on earth who genuinely doesn't believe in God. its impossible. they just embrace their sins a little too much and try to come up with excuses to justify their illegitimate denial of believing in Gods existence to make themselves feel less bad about sinning. they'll be trying until they're dead because its in our essence to know and feel bad for disobeying..

    So for the ones who act like they don't know... Y'all know! For every argument we can come up with, point you prove, or religion you dont support or understand... We dont need any of that.. Gods word is in us already, and He wants us to apply it.
    You do realize many of those "sins" were laws in other countries far before Christianity right? Christianity did not introduce the thought that murder and theft was wrong, that has been around much longer. They have not always been sins but they most definitely have been looked down upon for much longer than Christianity.

    And you're right, I don't need a bible or dictionary to know right from wrong. It is a sense of morals I possess that have been formed by growing up in a moral environment and not wanting to cause harm to others. If you think you need god to act with positive morals.....

    I think you're very arrogant to say no man does not believe in god, that is something you could never possibly know. Not to sound disrespectful (even though your claim is disrespectful to me) but you don't know what you're talking about in regards to what other people believe, you've been jaded by your religious views.

    As for your experiences, I'm very happy you came out of that alive...very lucky, keyword being luck. Being able to beats the odds is not proof of god, it's proof that sometimes you get a good hand. How many times does that same situation end badly? I'm willing to bet a lot more frequently than it turns out good. Does that mean those people should have prayed? No, it means the odds were stacked against them. Your attribution of survival to proof of god is nothing new and an easy one to pick apart. I know you're going to turn around and say I'm wrong and that you "know" god saved you that day but frankly you don't know, again your religious views jade you and allow you to claim knowledge of something that is impossible to know.
    Last edited by OnOneRyder; 02-27-2012 at 11:01 AM.

  5. #5
    Registered User God/Religion. Why? sayian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    north west ark
    Age
    41
    Posts
    203
    Blog Entries
    1

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Quote Originally Posted by OnOneRyder View Post
    You do realize many of those "sins" were laws in other countries far before Christianity right? Christianity did not introduce the thought that murder and theft was wrong, that has been around much longer. They have not always been sins but they most definitely have been looked down upon for much longer than Christianity.

    And you're right, I don't need a bible or dictionary to know right from wrong. It is a sense of morals I possess that have been formed by growing up in a moral environment and not wanting to cause harm to others. If you think you need god to act with positive morals.....

    I think you're very arrogant to say no man does not believe in god, that is something you could never possibly know. Not to sound disrespectful (even though your claim is disrespectful to me) but you don't know what you're talking about in regards to what other people believe, you've been jaded by your religious views.

    As for your experiences, I'm very happy you came out of that alive...very lucky, keyword being luck. Being able to beats the odds is not proof of god, it's proof that sometimes you get a good hand. How many times does that same situation end badly? I'm willing to bet a lot more frequently than it turns out good. Does that mean those people should have prayed? No, it means the odds were stacked against them. Your attribution of survival to proof of god is nothing new and an easy one to pick apart. I know you're going to turn around and say I'm wrong and that you "know" god saved you that day but frankly you don't know, again your religious views jade you and allow you to claim knowledge of something that is impossible to know.




    I apologize if u feel i disrespected you. I didnt come out stating blame, allegations or, "claims". I SAID, "Personally I dont believe".. I stated my thoughts and spoke from within. You call that arrogance when its really just peace of mind and faith.

    The 10 commandments (Gods words Himself) were established BEFORE Christianity. Before that word existed. Christianity (studied methods of Jesus during his time here on earth setting an example) modified the idea of compassion. That pretty much irrelevantized(<-word i just made up) that first argument..
    You may wanna look up the word survival and tell me where that applies in anything i said. And, its not "claim of knowledge", its recognizing moral consciousness.

    I have and established and understand my
    FAITH(theism)
    THEISM(yes im a believer)
    RELIGION (not needed)
    REASON(been tryna reason with this guy^) lol
    CORRELATION (my relationship with God was encouraged by, but was not establised via any religion, but acknowledging my essence)
    MORALITY(Gods word)
    CAUSATION(my faith and act on praying causes God to listen)
    RATIONALITY im not lucky.. lucky is something u try to get.. every time i go to the damn casino, i lose atleast $200.. that crackhead that sat and hit the jackpot next to me was lucky....lol call me stupid for that as well as unlucky. But, despite my many sins, i do believe in God and i know that chain of events that nite was not me getting "lucky".. had no control or knowledge of what was happening to keep me from killing myself on 4 occasions, but I made it home like i asked. and my vette is out of commission so i wouldnt keep driving like a bat outta hell while asleep..
    Last edited by sayian; 02-27-2012 at 04:23 PM.

  6. #6
    Only plays for sport Unknown Entity's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    Hiding behind your smile.
    Age
    34
    Posts
    4,052
    Blog Entries
    29

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Quote Originally Posted by RamesesII
    How do you differentiate between a god and fate or luck.
    I actually tried to find a picture in reply to you and sayian, but couldn't remember where I stumbled on to it. It's of someone going for a live saving operation, where this person's life will literally be in the hands of the surgeon that day. Yet that surgeon isn't thanked - God is. If it was God's way and the natural way of things, that person wouldn't be alive.

    Religion is a blind faith, no matter how you put it. I actually don't believe that there's a force or energy called "fate" or "luck", as if the results of them were premeditated. If I'd believed as so, then God probably would appeal to my beliefs as well.

    Fate is merely coincidence, same with luck I guess. People just like to think of fate as a better way of putting something, like a relationship or job application. "It was fate that we both fancied a coffee that lunch time, and locked eyes at that very moment in the coffee shop..." There's seven billion people in the world, and if it's anything like the four Starbucks outlets near my work, there were a lot of people fancying a coffee during their lunch break. I think stuff like that takes some control out of your life.

    Now luck is something different. It's more of a wish, surprise or state of approval. The lottery is based off of luck, and I dislike the math of trying to predict the winning numbers by averaging how many times each number has showed up and the likely-hood of it appearing again. Just because ball 23 has appeared x-number of times more than ball 33, ball 33 is more likely to get a chance some time soon - bullshit. I should hope that the balls are selected at complete random every time. Regardless on whether you picked your numbers yourself or got a lucky dip, it's pure luck if you win anything.

    I will hand it to religion for morals, and learning between right and wrong. The Bible is full of stories that teach morals. But I also think those same morals can be taught without a religion behind them. You don't need to teach blind faith to someone to get them to play nice. It depends on your upbringing and the values your parents teach you. I was raised as a Christian at school, and at home my mother kept religion in a safe place not quite near or too far when teaching me right from wrong. She wanted me to decide for myself if religion was for me. I wasn't a bad kid, and I've grown up pretty well. However, I'm not holding it against religion, but I was bullied by 90% of my class as a child in a Church of England school, where religion was supposedly supposed to teach right from wrong. Kids will be kids, and all that but I doubt religion makes for a better upbringing than a good parent would.

    I don't know about everyone else, but I think there being a higher force that dictates what you can and can't do, and had written your life story out before you've even lived it is a little depressing. What would be the point of anything if all you were is some role in someone else's sick fantasy?


    "I used to be active here like you, then I took an arrow in the knee."
    >>>------------->

    Suddenly... clutter.:

    Me and the lovely Joey is two cheeky chimpmonks, we is. Because TFF cousins can still... do stuff. ; )



    Quotes to have a giggle at.:

    Quote Originally Posted by Bleachfangirl
    I'm none too scary really. Just somewhat violent...
    Quote Originally Posted by MSN Convo
    Gemma the friggin' Entity. says:
    ^^;
    brb
    Bleachie says:
    Kay
    ...*runs around with a stick*
    I AM SPARTACUS!!!
    Hm, no one's here...
    TIME TO PARTY!
    Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
    Gemma the friggin' Entity. says:
    back
    Bleachie says:
    DARN IT
    Quote Originally Posted by Joe
    Now that we've apparently discussed wanting to see each other sleep with a game character... how goes?

    All my banners are now done by me! Soon, I will be great! Muwahahahaha... ha... eck! *coughs* ...ha!
    Biggest fan of Peanut Butter created by The Xeim and Halie Peanut Butter Corporation ^^



    Warning free for over eight years. Feels good.

  7. #7
    Asking all the personal questions. God/Religion. Why? RamesesII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    I am a god, where ever the hell I please.
    Age
    38
    Posts
    1,143
    Blog Entries
    1

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Quote Originally Posted by OnOneRyder View Post
    You do realize many of those "sins" were laws in other countries far before Christianity right? Christianity did not introduce the thought that murder and theft was wrong, that has been around much longer. They have not always been sins but they most definitely have been looked down upon for much longer than Christianity.
    .
    Similar to what I was going to say, people knew these things were wrong before the were so called written on the tablets from the mountain.
    Lest go back when homo sapiens first and only need was to survive, our one true thing that governed humans was instinct and still is in our genetic make up, may hap early man would have fought and killed each other if the need to survive was dire but as we started to evolve we learnt that we didn't have to cause destruction to survive as much so therefore we realised that killing someone was wrong and was unnecessary.

    Deep down every person has the capability of killing another human but only in the most dire of situations when all that is left is instinct and the willingness to survive, some people just have it closer to the surface than others. But I am going off track and rambling as usual.

    What I was trying to say is that there were many religions well before Christianity and even before these populations of people resorted to their gods, they knew right from wrong. There may have even been a populace that worship pregnant women, I mean why not a woman bringing new life into the world and back then miracle is an understatement so they were treated as deities. Maybe people believed in mother earth herself who isn't to say there was a Giaism. I know the indigenous people of Australia believed in the earth and the water and the sky, yeah the may have given these vital bringers of life metaphorical figures but that's why they called it the dreamtime.

    Quote Originally Posted by nix View Post

    Buddhism is older than any christian religion (by about 1500) and makes more sense.
    As is Taoism and even Sun religions such as the Egyptians ( I should know I am one ), Incas, Mayans and Aztecs why not the thing that gives light, grows plants essentially brings water, once again it's just the sun now we know today but what was it to them, the most powerful thing they could see that's what it was.


    Quote Originally Posted by Unknown Entity View Post

    Religion is a blind faith, no matter how you put it. I actually don't believe that there's a force or energy called "fate" or "luck", as if the results of them were premeditated. If I'd believed as so, then God probably would appeal to my beliefs as well.

    Fate is merely coincidence, same with luck I guess.
    Fate is "that which is inevitably predetermined" I dare say we should all believe in Fate, after all it is all our fate to die at some point in time. Even I the great Ramses the second will at some stage come to an end.

    This reminds me of a quote by Charles Darwin I think I can't remember correct me if I am wrong,
    how does it go "The only two certainties in life are death and taxes."

    EDIT- on further inspection it was Mark Twain who supposedly said this.
    Last edited by RamesesII; 02-28-2012 at 03:37 AM.
    A mouth of a perfectly happy man is filled with beer.
    --Ancient Egyptian Wisdom, 2200 B.C.



    Crao Porr Cock8, Go and get a Cock8 up ya.

    The finer details of a signature:


    CHE- "I pee sitting down after I have sex because for some reason after I have sex and I try to pee, it goes everywhere."
    Nuff said^


    My loving TFF Family:

    My beautiful go-go dancing Queen Aara
    My brother Meier Link, proudly supporting the World Wide Institute of Booze since 1982.
    My Spasmodic, spamtastic, spammer nephew Fate.
    My brother HUNK, he who wears the number 1 headband.
    My glowing Goddess of Egyptian thingy's, Unknown Entity.
    My Unique and unpredictable mother Kilala ^^.
    My little arcade freak brother nra4.
    My brother Captain of the Dragoon warriors, Mallick.
    My razzle, dazzle, razamatic, razphony brother Ralz
    My younger brother Ryu-Kentoshii Hirokima, the Legendary Samurai who Doesn't take "No" for an Answer.


    Literature:

    Recently read-
    Belgariad- David Eddings

    Currently Reading-
    The Tournament by Matthew Reilly


    Gaming:

    Currently PLaying

    -Minecraft
    - ASS Creed III





  8. #8

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Yeah but atleast the sun grants life and light on the earth and possibly elsewhere, we may have discovered other life in the universe if we didnt get hung up on religion, thats 2 amazing things more than the phantom god that does nothing at all but hamper the lives of humanity.

  9. #9

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    I kinda decided-- that I wanted to reply to this because I haven't actually considered what I would be term wise.

    I think I would fall between a agnostic theist and fideist. I believe in a a deity or god, but I would say that my beliefs are purely based upon faith; however, I can't prove anything based on faith alone. I do not believe it's necessary to follow a strict religion. In my mind, if there is a god, It is not necessary for me, a believer, to over exaggerate my faith through a religious praise and or practices. (Not that people who are religious or that follow one are doing so.)

    To keep it as simplified as possible, I feel that it is important to have beliefs, but organized religious are partially unnecessary, far too diverse, and far too complex, to take the place of non existent evidence. The fact that religions are so diverse, in a way, shows how it cannot serve as a universal piece of evidence to prove gods existence.
    Last edited by GypsyElder; 02-28-2012 at 11:41 PM.

    Ta DA!!!:

    Alright, who censored my rocketship?



    From The Clint Eastwood
    I'm thinking about creating a hybrid. A dolphin-monkey. Half dolphin, half monkey. Do you think it's possible?
    I was thinking that since I'm artificially creating it, I'll create it with rocket fuel instead of blood, and thus it will be able to fly, using the dolphin's dorsal fins as wings. And from the air, it will look down upon us all and protect us against sharks, and search for bananas.
    Block says:" this one time i got SUPER blazed and was riding with my friend to mcd's and i ran my fingers through my jew fro saying "I just feel like dancing"
    by Alpha: "Hate breeds hate. Love breeds love. F*ck real politik."
    Originally Posted by Michael Swayne
    I find Gypsy to be a very interesting person. In fact, when my hair grows out some more, Gypsy has already laid claim to it when I cut it again.

  10. #10
    Only plays for sport Unknown Entity's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    Hiding behind your smile.
    Age
    34
    Posts
    4,052
    Blog Entries
    29

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Quote Originally Posted by Sasquatch
    Claiming to know God's will and hinting that God has absolutely nothing to do with guiding science and medicine? No, that's not pompous at all.
    I didn't make a claim. I just don't think God plays a part in the advances we make. As humans, we long to find answers and to live long enough to see some. If God exists, he gave us a lifespan and many, many incurable aliments and diseases along with a lot of things that could kill us. What's to say he doesn't want the things he put into nature to take it's natural course?

    Just because you don't see the same thing as somebody else doesn't mean that they (or you) have any sort of blind faith. Faith in religion is just as "blind" as faith against religion.
    OnOneRyder pretty much summed up what I meant. You used what you know to be my beliefs in what I wrote against me.

    Religion is a blind faith. You can't see it, grasp it or taste it. You just have to believe, and have faith in what you believe. That's it. Doesn't make me against religion at all.


    "I used to be active here like you, then I took an arrow in the knee."
    >>>------------->

    Suddenly... clutter.:

    Me and the lovely Joey is two cheeky chimpmonks, we is. Because TFF cousins can still... do stuff. ; )



    Quotes to have a giggle at.:

    Quote Originally Posted by Bleachfangirl
    I'm none too scary really. Just somewhat violent...
    Quote Originally Posted by MSN Convo
    Gemma the friggin' Entity. says:
    ^^;
    brb
    Bleachie says:
    Kay
    ...*runs around with a stick*
    I AM SPARTACUS!!!
    Hm, no one's here...
    TIME TO PARTY!
    Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
    Gemma the friggin' Entity. says:
    back
    Bleachie says:
    DARN IT
    Quote Originally Posted by Joe
    Now that we've apparently discussed wanting to see each other sleep with a game character... how goes?

    All my banners are now done by me! Soon, I will be great! Muwahahahaha... ha... eck! *coughs* ...ha!
    Biggest fan of Peanut Butter created by The Xeim and Halie Peanut Butter Corporation ^^



    Warning free for over eight years. Feels good.

  11. #11
    Boxer of the Galaxy God/Religion. Why? Rowan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Age
    35
    Posts
    3,108

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Quote Originally Posted by Unknown Entity View Post
    Religion is a blind faith. You can't see it, grasp it or taste it. You just have to believe, and have faith in what you believe.
    Not to mention, but in many religions, you are not allowed to question it. I think its very valid point to make since all religions should be looked at as equally valid/invalid as each other.

    I think its time we talked about why some religions are more popular than others. How has christianity forced its way into the netherlands, wiping out the beliefs of norse mythology. How has it began to dominate the entire world.

    Christianity by country - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    My only thoughts toward this are in its organisation. It is obviously the most organised and talked about religion. We see it in movies, television and celebreate supposed christian holidays without even knowing it. I say supposed because the holidays were stolen (date and festivities) from traditions pre-dating the religion itself. I'll refer you to this image.


  12. #12
    I do what you can't. God/Religion. Why? Sasquatch's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Here and there
    Age
    40
    Posts
    1,983

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Keep in mind, this is a general post, and not in direct reply to any one person ...

    We get it.

    You don't believe in the same religion as somebody else might. We get it. That's your right. You believe whatever you want. Good for you.

    But again -- just because you don't follow the same religious belief as somebody else does not mean that they are somehow stupid. So drop the arrogant attempt at a mental superiority complex, it's really annoying. (And slightly amusingly ironic, considering most of the ones trying to employ it.)

    I'll try to make an example that's easy to understand and relate to.

    My truck is in my garage. My garage is not empty, there is not somebody else's vehicle in my garage, it's my truck. I firmly believe that. My faith in that idea is very strong -- so much so, in fact, that I would be comfortable saying that I know that my truck is in my garage.

    Now, do I actually know that for a fact? Well, since I'm not in my garage looking at my truck's VIN, of course I don't -- for all I know, somebody could have stolen my truck, or the garage might have burned down, or aliens might have warped my truck out to their planet and replaced it with a hologram. But I have faith that my truck is in my garage, and for good reasons.

    Do you know where I live? Does anybody here know where I live? If you happened to drive past my place, you would see my home, my garage, and even my truck.

    That makes sense, right? You'd see my truck. Just making sure you're still with me, here.

    But would you know what it was? Would you know that it's my truck, in my garage? Of course not. You just don't have the reasons that I do to believe that.

    And that's all it boils down to. You don't have the same reasons we do for believing -- whether it's a religion or whether it's whose truck is in whose garage. And that's it. We may see the same things, but we see them differently, and with different reasons behind them.

    So get the **** over it. As much as Atheists bitch and moan about having religion "shoved down their throats", here they are, insulting the religions of others. Obviously, you won't believe the same things as I do, because you haven't seen the same things.

    Now, you might claim that people who have seen the same things are not credible or trustworthy, but here's the thing ... This may surprise you, so make sure you're sitting down. Ready? Alright, here we go.

    NOBODY GIVES A SHIT WHAT YOU THINK.

    I'm not sure if that's something new to you, or if you're used to being extremely unimportant, but it should be the latter. Really, do you think that if one ignorant little child on the internet was enough to make people lose their religion, that you would be the first? People believe different things than you do. So get over it. You're not smarter or better than anybody because you believe differently -- on the contrary, pretending that you are better proves otherwise. I don't know where you think you learned about any specific religion, but for the one you're attacking, the entire idea of blind faith that we're not allowed to question is not just incorrect, it's stupid.

    We have our beliefs that have been reinforced by what we've been exposed to. So do you.

    Sig courtesy of Plastik Assassin.


    Greater love hath no man than this; that he lay down his life for his friends.
    John 15:13

  13. #13

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    That was quite the long winded rant about an argument you've proposed before which I have also addressed before. Your truck has always been there in the past and nothing is out of the ordinary to suggest anything has changed. Yes there are alternate potentials, but your inclusion of faith in your description of your beliefs is completely unnecessary. Faith is not required for the example you've given as you can utilize past experiences as evidence to support your conclusion, patterns can and are used as evidence in scientific theories. Faith is used when proof is absent.

    I also get it, you think you're thinking rationally in regards to your beliefs. That's fine, you're entitled to think that but as soon as you choose to share your beliefs in a discussion forum expect to have them questioned. Quit getting your panties in a knot that I question such bold claims as miracles without so much as an example. Claims of "knowledge" when such knowledge cannot be reasonably known should be questioned, especially when the person making the claim poorly articulates their thoughts. Not to be too condescending, but I do question the ability of someone to think rationally when they have a difficult time conveying relatively simplistic thoughts or when the posts they present are lacking in intellectual quality. Call me arrogant all you like, I don't claim intellectual superiority over people for their beliefs in god. I listen to what they have to say and reserve my verdict until after and if they show me the religious bias they have in their logic, or their total lack of modern science through ignorance or arrogance.

    So get the **** over it. As much as Atheists bitch and moan about having religion "shoved down their throats", here they are, insulting the religions of others. Obviously, you won't believe the same things as I do, because you haven't seen the same things.
    Questioning someone's beliefs is not not synonymous with insulting their beliefs, if that is your take on what the non-theists do in this thread then that's unfortunate. Why should we feel the need to dull the words we use to question beliefs in a book which we believe to be an insult to us?

    You're right I won't, I asked the previous poster to cite examples and you go off on a childish tirade? The discussion doesn't end when you think it ends, if you wish to not be a part of it feel free to hit the back button and find another thread.
    Last edited by OnOneRyder; 03-05-2012 at 08:26 PM.

  14. #14
    I do what you can't. God/Religion. Why? Sasquatch's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Here and there
    Age
    40
    Posts
    1,983

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    [EDIT: Awwww look, I got negative rep with the comment of "your vagina is showing". It would be sad anyway, but it's made moreso -- and much more comedic -- by being remarked by a person who recently claimed that he/she has "plenty intelligent to say". Tell you what, it's too bad I won't be around them when some people move out of mommy and daddy's house and realize that the real world doesn't find extreme immaturity in any way appealing. It would be fun to watch.]

    Quote Originally Posted by OnOneRyder View Post
    Yes there are alternate potentials, but your inclusion of faith in your description of your beliefs is completely unnecessary. Faith is not required for the example you've given as you can utilize past experiences as evidence to support your conclusion, patterns can and are used as evidence in scientific theories. Faith is used when proof is absent.
    As I have shown you before, not all faith is blind. Continual assertion despite being proven wrong (unless dictionaries are more theist propaganda and thus untrustworthy to you) is more than willful ignorance, it's complete denial of proven truth.

    Unless I am in the process of confirming the VIN of the truck in my garage, I must rely on faith. I have absolutely no proof -- not from fifty yards away, out of line-of-sight. Just because it's not faith in a higher power does not mean that it isn't faith at all. And just because it's based on the evidence we've seen (as I explained before, you may not have seen the same evidence) doesn't mean it's not faith. Nobody is without faith.

    I also get it, you think you're thinking rationally in regards to your beliefs.
    And the constant arrogant idea that people with faith that isn't yours are automatically irrational isn't helping your argument.

    Call me arrogant all you like, I don't claim intellectual superiority over people for their beliefs in god. I listen to what they have to say and reserve my verdict until after and if they show me the religious bias they have in their logic, or their total lack of modern science through ignorance or arrogance.
    Right -- you listen to what they have to say, until you deduce that they don't share the same faith, then you berate and insult them. I've noticed.

    Questioning someone's beliefs is not not synonymous with insulting their beliefs, if that is your take on what the non-theists do in this thread then that's unfortunate.
    You're right -- questioning someone's beliefs is not synonymous with insulting their beliefs. But claiming that someone's beliefs are "bullshit", telling people that they're irrational or foolish or ignorant for having a different faith, intentionally twisting and manipulating both scripture and statistics ... That's not "questioning" anything, that's insulting.

    You're right I won't, I asked the previous poster to cite examples and you go off on a childish tirade?
    I'm not quite sure how you got the idea that I was replying directly to you -- especially when I didn't quote anybody and specifically said, as the first statement of my post, that it was a general post and not a direct reply to any one person. I'm really not sure how much clearer I could have made that. You were one straw on the camel's back.

    Quote Originally Posted by Telegraph View Post
    Yeah, gotta remember sassy, the first post of this thread set this thing up as a debate. Said specifically that it was intended as such, and that if you felt that someone didn't explain their beliefs to your liking, not to back down about telling them so.
    It was set up from the OP as a place to explain what and why we do or don't believe, not as a place to insult others because their faith is different from our own. It started off pretty civil, with many good points by those with all kinds of faiths, but it wasn't long before it devolved into "if you don't share my beliefs, you're illogical/irrational."

    I have a wonderful group of friends who have stuck together since Middle School, and they are all Christians now, but they didn't used to be. One was very much an atheist at one point, and wanted God to come face to face with him and tell him He was real. Another was a pagan, and another a Wiccan. Through the course of High School though, these diverse viewpoints and belief systems all came to Christianity.
    They were just adjusting their faith to the evidence that they had seen and how they interpreted it, just as people of any other faiths.

    I won't say that I am super educated on the subject of all origin theories or science in general, but I know enough to know that they haven't found a satisfactory answer yet. All they're doing is taking "Not Creator" and putting it in the place of "Creator," with no great amount of proof that their "Not Creator" is even a viable answer. If they were honest, they would simply say that they don't know how everything was created yet. But there can't be a God/creator, right? Let's just squash that notion right now.
    Exactly. Much of "science" is based on the idea that there must be a scientific explanation for everything because no supernatural being exists, even if it means attributing supernatural powers to natural causes, ignoring established laws of physics and thermodynamics -- but, apparently, it's alright if "science" claims that these established scientific and natural laws were broken through natural events, as long as they weren't broken by supernatural events. It makes no sense.

    Quote Originally Posted by Unknown Entity View Post
    I also think these matters are allowed to be questioned, for others to gather insight on what we all believe.
    Not just allowed, but encouraged, I'd say. And while there are huge differences between insulting and questioning, I welcome and encourage questions to my own faith (as, I believe, we all should). Faith is pointless without something to back it up, whatever that faith may concern.

    In all fairness Sas, I don't think you can compare a faith in God to that of having faith that your truck is in your garage.
    It wasn't so much a comparison as it was a likening of faith. I just wanted to illustrate the point that faith in itself is a foolish concept to insult, as we all have faith in many things, whether they be religious or not, based on our own experiences.

    You've seen your garage, you've seen your truck, you've driven it, you've probably had a good whiff of gas fumes from it, and you'd probably hear someone attempting to steal your truck (assuming your garage is close). Do you have faith that God is somewhere? Where is "somewhere"? Have you touched, tasted or seen God?
    While I may not have touched, tasted, or seen God, I have seen what I interpret to be signs and works of Him -- and I haven't touched my truck today, or my brain, or you, but I still have reason enough to believe that all of those things exist.

    A belief or disbelief in God makes you no more intelligent or worthy of an opinion.
    This part, I just wanted to quote for truth.

    And Heartless Angel, while you have been in this thread (and in most) one of the more civil, that last post of yours might be the most respectful and respectable of this thread, especially from a non-theist. So, in whichever way you want to take it ... Kudos.
    Last edited by Sasquatch; 03-06-2012 at 01:39 PM.

    Sig courtesy of Plastik Assassin.


    Greater love hath no man than this; that he lay down his life for his friends.
    John 15:13

  15. #15
    I invented Go-Gurt. God/Religion. Why? Clint's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Delaware
    Age
    36
    Posts
    1,647

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Sassy, you need better coverage.

    Quote Originally Posted by Sasquatch View Post
    And the constant arrogant idea that people with faith that isn't yours are automatically irrational isn't helping your argument.
    Despite what anybody else thinks, your irrational and blind faith in religion is not superseded by the irrational blind faith against religion of another. You talk to me about immaturity, but you're the one behaving like a child. You're a hypocrite, Sassypants.


    Quote Originally Posted by Sasquatch View Post
    Right -- you listen to what they have to say, until you deduce that they don't share the same faith, then you berate and insult them. I've noticed.
    Hey, that's the exact same thing you do!

    Quote Originally Posted by Sasquatch View Post
    But claiming that someone's beliefs are "bullshit", telling people that they're irrational or foolish or ignorant for having a different faith, intentionally twisting and manipulating both scripture and statistics ... That's not "questioning" anything, that's insulting.
    That's exactly right. It's not questioning at all. What you described is what I described earlier. Blind faith against religion. There is no purpose other then "I don't like this belief because it doesn't match my beliefs, and I want to be right." However, your stereotype in your previous post concerning the beliefs of atheism doesn't help the situation. It escalates the situation and makes anybody who shares atheistic beliefs angry.

    Both sides of the spectrum are wrong, whether you're arguing for or against your own beliefs. Faith is called faith for a reason. You don't need to prove that you're right, because if you believe, then you have nothing to prove. You don't need anybody else to believe you, and you don't need to defend your beliefs from jackasses attempting to insult them. Sticks and stones, my friend. Words mean nothing.


    Quote Originally Posted by Sasquatch View Post
    Much of "science" is based on the idea that there must be a scientific explanation for everything because no supernatural being exists,
    That's wrong. Science isn't a concern for religion. It doesn't try to disprove anything. All it does is to try to figure out answers as to why things happen and why things are the way that they are. Any unexplained scientific phenomenon isn't attributed to supernatural powers, the answer to the question just hasn't been discovered yet.


    Quote Originally Posted by Sasquatch View Post
    that last post of yours might be the most respectful and respectable of this thread, especially from a non-theist.
    I just wanted to quote this to point out the vocabulary used. The part that intrigued me was "especially from a non-theist," as if somehow anybody's beliefs have anything to do with respectability. You go off on people who don't believe the same as you do because they've insulted your beliefs, but that right there is an insult to them personally, not just to their beliefs.

  16. #16

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Quote Originally Posted by Sasquatch View Post

    As I have shown you before, not all faith is blind. Continual assertion despite being proven wrong (unless dictionaries are more theist propaganda and thus untrustworthy to you) is more than willful ignorance, it's complete denial of proven truth.
    Faith in the supposed claim you KNOW there is a deity as described in religious texts is 100% blind.

    Unless I am in the process of confirming the VIN of the truck in my garage, I must rely on faith. I have absolutely no proof -- not from fifty yards away, out of line-of-sight. Just because it's not faith in a higher power does not mean that it isn't faith at all. And just because it's based on the evidence we've seen (as I explained before, you may not have seen the same evidence) doesn't mean it's not faith. Nobody is without faith.
    You clearly completely misunderstand what constitutes proof, evidence and deductive reasoning. The fact that you think that is a sound argument boggles my mind.

    And the constant arrogant idea that people with faith that isn't yours are automatically irrational isn't helping your argument.
    I wasn't claiming your belief in your rationality was wrong, I'm sorry if you misconstrued that. You went off on a tangent about how you get what non-theists think and that no further discussion was needed, I spat it back in your face. Pot meet kettle.

    Right -- you listen to what they have to say, until you deduce that they don't share the same faith, then you berate and insult them. I've noticed.
    No, I poke holes in their beliefs where I think they have weaknesses.

    You're right -- questioning someone's beliefs is not synonymous with insulting their beliefs. But claiming that someone's beliefs are "bullshit", telling people that they're irrational or foolish or ignorant for having a different faith, intentionally twisting and manipulating both scripture and statistics ... That's not "questioning" anything, that's insulting.
    I don't attack a person solely for having a belief in god, I criticize their justifications for those beliefs. If my crudeness comes off an insult it's usually because I'm directing my thoughts towards an individual claiming to "know" anything about a god.

    Where have I twisted scripture or statistics? Speaking of statistics, how about that claim that religious people are more charitable, peaceful and lawful?

    Exactly. Much of "science" is based on the idea that there must be a scientific explanation for everything because no supernatural being exists, even if it means attributing supernatural powers to natural causes, ignoring established laws of physics and thermodynamics -- but, apparently, it's alright if "science" claims that these established scientific and natural laws were broken through natural events, as long as they weren't broken by supernatural events. It makes no sense.
    You do realize that for something to be considered and accepted as scientific truth all the pieces have to come together right? There are an endless amount of theories coming from an endless amount of individuals. Sure you're going to have people way out in left field making extraordinary claims, are they ever widely considered as factual? If so please cite examples, accreditation providing you with the knowledge to make those judgements would be swell as well.

    While I may not have touched, tasted, or seen God, I have seen what I interpret to be signs and works of Him -- and I haven't touched my truck today, or my brain, or you, but I still have reason enough to believe that all of those things exist.
    Those things you've seen also probably have a natural explanations or are the product of chance. Theists often attribute the unlikeliness and odds stacked against a situation occurring yet each and everyone of us exists because we beat the odds of millions of other sperm. What do you think the odds are that from your and my fathers sperm that you and I are the ones here today having a discussion? Feel free to do the math, the odds were hugely against us. Is our existence against those odds proof of the divine, absolutely not. I realize that may not be your reasoning, but I bet it can be used as an argument against your reasons.

    especially from a non-theist
    You're so much more civil. You were involved with a lot of "he hit me first!" situations as a kid, weren't you?

  17. #17
    Mr. Person Taco-Calamitous's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2001
    Location
    Oregon
    Age
    41
    Posts
    5,705
    Blog Entries
    17

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Yeah, gotta remember sassy, the first post of this thread set this thing up as a debate. Said specifically that it was intended as such, and that if you felt that someone didn't explain their beliefs to your liking, not to back down about telling them so. It also said "no name calling," but the thread's already failed there

    I agree with you though, that there's nothing anyone on a message board can say that's going to shake someone's belief systems so much that they're going to change their minds about everything. To assume that you as some block of text on the internet can do as much is fairly arrogant. However, this thread was meant for debate. It's not going to accomplish anything but cause bad feelings between people and reaffirm those who think they're smarter than everyone else, but eh. That's why I usually don't post in these things. Personally, though...

    I believe in the Christian God, and Jesus Christ. I was born into a Catholic family, and events throughout my life have only reaffirmed my faith. I have a wonderful group of friends who have stuck together since Middle School, and they are all Christians now, but they didn't used to be. One was very much an atheist at one point, and wanted God to come face to face with him and tell him He was real. Another was a pagan, and another a Wiccan. Through the course of High School though, these diverse viewpoints and belief systems all came to Christianity.

    We've also seen loved ones survive sickness when they were supposed to die. One guy's father was supposed to not survive the night, and my friends all went to the hospital to pray for him. He survived. More recently, his grandpa was supposed to have surgery on the heart that no one has survived before. We prayed for him, and he lived. The Lord has come through for us in other ways, too. Unexpected funds when we were running low on money, difficult tasks made substantially easier, comfort in dark times...

    Furthermore, I love the figure of Jesus and the example that he set. Whenever I read the Gospel, I'm filled with a warm feeling inside. Living by his example is something to strive for, although I can't say I'm doing the best job ever at that, always. Also, Jesus was a historical figure. There are documents about him from that time period. Some people claim that they aren't legitimate. I don't know that I should take their word for it.

    Beyond all that, I have taken college level courses in biology, I've done some study of physics, I have a general knowledge of such things, and my recent ASVAB scores would suggest I've got a fairly decent grasp. I have a friend who is much more knowledgeable on the subject than I am, as well; one of his hobbies is reading biology, chemistry, quantum physics books, etc., on his own time, heh. He could probably explain much better than me... but nothing we've ever come across that science has put forth to be the answer to the origin of the universe or life has ever been convincing to us. That lightning striking the water theory? That space dust being in perfect order to become a life form somehow, just by accident? I am not convinced. And I am aware that the more some scientists have studied the beginning of the universe, the more they are led to believe that all of this couldn't have started on its own. I've even heard that Stephen Hawking thought this at one point.

    I won't say that I am super educated on the subject of all origin theories or science in general, but I know enough to know that they haven't found a satisfactory answer yet. All they're doing is taking "Not Creator" and putting it in the place of "Creator," with no great amount of proof that their "Not Creator" is even a viable answer. If they were honest, they would simply say that they don't know how everything was created yet. But there can't be a God/creator, right? Let's just squash that notion right now.

    I am well aware that there are likely holes in my argument, that anyone who's already posted in this thread (or hasn't) will likely not be swayed by anything I said. These are simply the reasons why I believe what I believe. As human beings, we tend to take whatever information reaffirms our beliefs (or "mindsets") and ignore that which detracts from it. You're going to believe what you want to believe, regardless of what anyone says. Any change in your beliefs ("mindset") is going to come from change within you, and not from what anyone else tells you. So... my final conclusion is that this debate is pointless. I could go look for links to back up what I've said, but I don't feel like it, and my sources would probably be refuted by somebody anyway. Go ahead and respond to me. I probably won't say anything else. Anyhoo...

    Wuv, Yer Mom

  18. #18
    Only plays for sport Unknown Entity's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    Hiding behind your smile.
    Age
    34
    Posts
    4,052
    Blog Entries
    29

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    I've never understood why debates such as this can be taken so personally. We live in a very diverse world, so there's bound to be a difference of opinion on many matters. I also think these matters are allowed to be questioned, for others to gather insight on what we all believe. And you know what? I believe certain opinions can change someone else's outlook on religion if done correctly. All I've seen in this thread is people undermining each other over their opinion. I honestly think it'll do everyone good to listen once in a while, and gain some knowledge.

    In all fairness Sas, I don't think you can compare a faith in God to that of having faith that your truck is in your garage. If you're telling me you've touched and rode God, I think you have a lot of explaining to do and may need a padded room (/trying to be funny but doubts it'll work much). You've seen your garage, you've seen your truck, you've driven it, you've probably had a good whiff of gas fumes from it, and you'd probably hear someone attempting to steal your truck (assuming your garage is close). Do you have faith that God is somewhere? Where is "somewhere"? Have you touched, tasted or seen God?

    If anything, if I believed in God, it'd be more of a feeling of someone powerful watching over me. I wouldn't be able to pin-point a place from which they look, but I'd feel them. Like walking out my house on a hot summer afternoon. I'm not telling you how you should feel - I just find your definition of faith weird.

    So didn't mean for my post to come off as homo in some ways. Also, I'll make it damn clear: I'm not attacking anyone with this post. We clear? 'Cos if we're not, I might skip a few posts in case they contain some snarky comments to do with my intellect.


    I've heard some beliefs around God being the force of creation instead of a man. I've never quite decided if it's a last minute argument that God can be proved or if it's a reasonable explanation into the existence of God. I think religion has been built up around our need to discover who we are and where we came from, so it could be both. I don't think God can be proven scientifically, but I think it'll definitely be tried by most people, and I do think something discovered by science will undoubtedly be named "God" by believers.

    Humanoids have walked this Earth for over 3million years with us Homo Sapiens walking the Earth for over 100,000 years. The oldest known human-made religious structure is Göbekli Tepe, Turkey, which is believed to have been built around 12,000 years ago, so you have to believe that religion has been around for a long time. But what was the purpose of Göbekli Tepe? It's believed it was a place of worship for hunters who gathered food. It's likely, going by the carvings and scattered animal bones, that these people worshipped animals and not specifically a God.

    I think as we developed into humanity, so did religion. Different religions have popped up ever since, with the oldest recorded religion being Hinduism (5500–2600 BCE), and the concept of God [in Hinduism] has always been complex, and really depends on the person and what they believe in. Christianity is waaay younger with the earliest reports from the first third of the first century. That doesn't make it any less of a religion at all, but I believe that religion has just evolved with us. The Bible was written over a period of 1,400 to 1,800 years by more than forty different authors with as little as the inspiration of the belief in God. That's a lot of time to evolve beliefs.

    Why did it take us so long to develop a belief in a God? Surely we'd have known about him far sooner than that?

    I'm done for the time being. I just want it to be known that these are my beliefs plus some looking up I've done this morning. I'm happy for (and expect) people to comment on it, but I do ask for respect. None of this undermining shit. A belief or disbelief in God makes you no more intelligent or worthy of an opinion.
    Last edited by Unknown Entity; 03-05-2012 at 08:25 PM.


    "I used to be active here like you, then I took an arrow in the knee."
    >>>------------->

    Suddenly... clutter.:

    Me and the lovely Joey is two cheeky chimpmonks, we is. Because TFF cousins can still... do stuff. ; )



    Quotes to have a giggle at.:

    Quote Originally Posted by Bleachfangirl
    I'm none too scary really. Just somewhat violent...
    Quote Originally Posted by MSN Convo
    Gemma the friggin' Entity. says:
    ^^;
    brb
    Bleachie says:
    Kay
    ...*runs around with a stick*
    I AM SPARTACUS!!!
    Hm, no one's here...
    TIME TO PARTY!
    Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
    Gemma the friggin' Entity. says:
    back
    Bleachie says:
    DARN IT
    Quote Originally Posted by Joe
    Now that we've apparently discussed wanting to see each other sleep with a game character... how goes?

    All my banners are now done by me! Soon, I will be great! Muwahahahaha... ha... eck! *coughs* ...ha!
    Biggest fan of Peanut Butter created by The Xeim and Halie Peanut Butter Corporation ^^



    Warning free for over eight years. Feels good.

  19. #19
    The Mad God God/Religion. Why? Heartless Angel's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    New Sheoth
    Age
    35
    Posts
    1,970

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Quote Originally Posted by Sasquatch

    You don't believe in the same religion as somebody else might. We get it. That's your right. You believe whatever you want. Good for you.

    But again -- just because you don't follow the same religious belief as somebody else does not mean that they are somehow stupid. So drop the arrogant attempt at a mental superiority complex, it's really annoying. (And slightly amusingly ironic, considering most of the ones trying to employ it.)
    I also value and accept each and every person's right to believe whatever they like, however not all beliefs have the support of a valid argument, which is generally what a debate is based on. Though you said that post was directed at no one, I'll assume at least a part of it was in response to me, if not my apologies, but I feel the need to clarify this anyways.

    When I disagree with a person and poke holes in an argument, it is because I see flaws within the logic that makes the argument as a whole weak, and unable to carry the weight of its conclusion. This isn't to attack the belief itself, merely to make each and every person question their reasons for believing something. If one's only reason for having a belief were the evidence they had for it, and I was able to prove that that evidence was unable to support the conclusion, someone might reexamine the evidence and find another solution. When a group of people are working to find the answer to a complicated question, being proven wrong is not a bad thing. It allows us to stop working under an inaccurate assumption, and move on to finding a better one, getting closer and closer to absolute truth. I don't argue to sound superior or feel superior or any such nonsense, my intellect, whether what it actually is or what it is perceived to be by those around me is entirely irrelevant. Being wrong, or having a flawed argument doesn't make a person stupid, nor does being stupid make a person's arguments worth any less. Debates of this sort should be conducted solely for the purpose of evaluating the worth of ideas, that we may better understand them. Challenging an idea, whether that challenge 'defeats' the idea or not, helps us to move ever closer to truth. I don't argue because I think I'm intelligent, on the contrary, I argue to become more intelligent. I argue because I am perfectly aware of my own uncertainty, and wish to test the strength of my ideas and others, to see which ideas are most worthy of belief. When I offer a poor argument and someone comes and kicks its ass with valid arguments, solid evidence, and worthwhile ideas, I learn from them, I don't feel personally threatened, nor is it my intention to make others feel that way when I poke holes in an argument.

    My truck is in my garage. My garage is not empty, there is not somebody else's vehicle in my garage, it's my truck. I firmly believe that. My faith in that idea is very strong -- so much so, in fact, that I would be comfortable saying that I know that my truck is in my garage.

    Now, do I actually know that for a fact? Well, since I'm not in my garage looking at my truck's VIN, of course I don't -- for all I know, somebody could have stolen my truck, or the garage might have burned down, or aliens might have warped my truck out to their planet and replaced it with a hologram. But I have faith that my truck is in my garage, and for good reasons.

    Do you know where I live? Does anybody here know where I live? If you happened to drive past my place, you would see my home, my garage, and even my truck.

    That makes sense, right? You'd see my truck. Just making sure you're still with me, here.

    But would you know what it was? Would you know that it's my truck, in my garage? Of course not. You just don't have the reasons that I do to believe that.

    And that's all it boils down to. You don't have the same reasons we do for believing -- whether it's a religion or whether it's whose truck is in whose garage. And that's it. We may see the same things, but we see them differently, and with different reasons behind them.
    In the end, regardless of who sees what and how they interpret it, your truck either is or is not in your garage. It doesn't really matter what anybody thought about it or if they were right or wrong. The truth doesn't care who understands it. When we compare and contrast our ideas, discarding those which the evidence does not support, we come closer to understanding the truth of the matter. To discard the ideas that are not truth, we examine our reasons for believing them, and the evidence in reality. The sum of these two parts is an argument. By comparing arguments in a debate, we seek to determine which idea is more worthy of belief. This doesn't mean we demand the 'losers' to abandon their belief, simply to point out that their arguments have not yet established truth. We all have the right to believe anything, we are born with this right, but the right to know the truth, that must be earned, and this is the process.

    As much as Atheists bitch and moan about having religion "shoved down their throats", here they are, insulting the religions of others. Obviously, you won't believe the same things as I do, because you haven't seen the same things.

    Now, you might claim that people who have seen the same things are not credible or trustworthy, but here's the thing ... This may surprise you, so make sure you're sitting down. Ready? Alright, here we go.

    NOBODY GIVES A SHIT WHAT YOU THINK.


    When one enters into a debate by observing conflicting ideas claiming to be truth, they consent to hearing and considering the ideas of another based upon their arguments, it's not being shoved down one's throat, it's being offered along with a reason why it should be accepted. This is normal, and perfectly acceptable. On occasion however, someone sets the stage for such a debate, but then ignores the rules, trying to claim knowledge of truth without having earned the right to that claim. When one claims their idea is truth, and that all others must accept it without being able to justify that claim, that is shoving ones idea down someone else's throat. That comes from both sides, not just the theists'. One usually doesn't see such things in a debate such as this. When one does, as can be seen here, it is usually shot down quickly with a barrage of questions.
    I'm not sure if that's something new to you, or if you're used to being extremely unimportant, but it should be the latter. Really, do you think that if one ignorant little child on the internet was enough to make people lose their religion, that you would be the first?
    It is not my intention to make anybody lose their religion, nor do I believe it's anyone elses. If it is, I am forced to say they are morons. With these arguments, nobody has proven that there is no God or that any religion is wrong, simply that it has not earned the right to declare itself the truth. Opinions are fine as long as we keep in mind, that is all they are. When we try to act as though they are facts, we must be able to support them as such. If we can't, we do not have the right to treat them as facts.

    We have our beliefs that have been reinforced by what we've been exposed to. So do you.
    We all do. It's impossible to not have some belief, some idea of what we think is the truth. But as long as we acknowledge they are nothing more than beliefs, this isn't a problem. When we bring beliefs to a debate, it isn't to destroy the beliefs of others, simply to determine whether any of them qualify to become more than just a belief. Ideas of religion and the existence of the divine have been struggling to be accepted as truth for ages without success, but the beliefs are still alive and well no matter how many times they failed to earn the right to be called the truth. This will continue until one DOES earn the right to be called truth by proving itself with certainty. If this day ever comes, other ideas will be abandoned, but I don't see this day coming any time soon, so we really don't have much to worry about.

    Having a good argument doesn't always mean we walk away with answers. In fact I'm most satisfied when we walk away with new, better questions. That's what we acomplish here by proving the arguments which support each other's beliefs wrong.

    Quote Originally Posted by Telegraph
    I believe in the Christian God, and Jesus Christ. I was born into a Catholic family, and events throughout my life have only reaffirmed my faith. I have a wonderful group of friends who have stuck together since Middle School, and they are all Christians now, but they didn't used to be. One was very much an atheist at one point, and wanted God to come face to face with him and tell him He was real. Another was a pagan, and another a Wiccan. Through the course of High School though, these diverse viewpoints and belief systems all came to Christianity.
    People's beliefs do change when they find new more compelling evidence for a position they had not previously held. I myself started out a Christian, raised Lutheran, then when I discovered the evidence science offered me, finding it to be much more compelling than anything the church ever offered me, became atheist. Now, at a later stage in my development as a critical thinker, having been forced to reexamine my beliefs by the debates of those and with those far smarter than myself, have become agnostic.

    We've also seen loved ones survive sickness when they were supposed to die. One guy's father was supposed to not survive the night, and my friends all went to the hospital to pray for him. He survived. More recently, his grandpa was supposed to have surgery on the heart that no one has survived before. We prayed for him, and he lived. The Lord has come through for us in other ways, too. Unexpected funds when we were running low on money, difficult tasks made substantially easier, comfort in dark times...
    While those are all things worthy of celebration, and would make one inclined to want to thank someone responsible, they don't prove the belief to be truth. If however everyone who prayed recovered, or everyone who prayed got what they needed to get by, there might be something to this line of reasoning, but far too often people who doctors say won't make it through the night, in spite of their prayers, don't make it through the night. Those who pray for recovery from serious injuries all their life, but still never recover. Those who fall on hard times, pray for a miracle, but remain poor, hungry or homeless. Many even die. Witnessing what we perceive as miracles may shape our beliefs, but can't give us knowledge of the truth unless we can also know they were miracles by understanding how they happened, and that there was no possible way it could have been without magic. This is unfortunately nearly impossible to prove, and all attempts at it throughout history have fallen short.

    ... but nothing we've ever come across that science has put forth to be the answer to the origin of the universe or life has ever been convincing to us. That lightning striking the water theory? That space dust being in perfect order to become a life form somehow, just by accident? I am not convinced. And I am aware that the more some scientists have studied the beginning of the universe, the more they are led to believe that all of this couldn't have started on its own. I've even heard that Stephen Hawking thought this at one point.
    It has been convincing to many. The big bang theory and the theory of evolution are widely accepted in spite of not having been proven beyond all doubt. It's not just you that hasn't been convinced that it's absolute truth though. Scientists haven't either. That's why they question their own ideas, call their findings theories instead of laws, keep looking into the matter rather than just saying, "Yeah, we already figured that out, let's move on to the next thing and never ask this question again".

    I won't say that I am super educated on the subject of all origin theories or science in general, but I know enough to know that they haven't found a satisfactory answer yet. All they're doing is taking "Not Creator" and putting it in the place of "Creator," with no great amount of proof that their "Not Creator" is even a viable answer. If they were honest, they would simply say that they don't know how everything was created yet. But there can't be a God/creator, right? Let's just squash that notion right now.
    Those who claim to know that there is no creator are every bit as arrogant and foolish as those who claim they know there is. Neither position has earned the right to be called truth. Not yet. The honest answer IS I don't know. Nobody knows. We all believe something happened, but we don't know.

    I am well aware that there are likely holes in my argument, that anyone who's already posted in this thread (or hasn't) will likely not be swayed by anything I said.
    Nothing personal, but as a critical thinker, I would almost go so far as to say it is my duty to not be swayed easily, and to question everything until there are no questions left to ask.

    These are simply the reasons why I believe what I believe. As human beings, we tend to take whatever information reaffirms our beliefs (or "mindsets") and ignore that which detracts from it. You're going to believe what you want to believe, regardless of what anyone says. Any change in your beliefs ("mindset") is going to come from change within you, and not from what anyone else tells you.

    So... my final conclusion is that this debate is pointless.
    That's a fine answer. I respect it, and you for it. You're not so arrogant as to claim that belief as absolute knowledge, acknowledging that things have simply led you to believe that rather than proving it to be the truth. But another thought for you to ponder, is it not entirely possible that what others tell you could cause that change within? I would in fact assume that what led me to reexamine my beliefs and change them was the input of those I considered to be smarter than myself. When someone offers me an answer, I am usually quick to dismiss it if they haven't proven it and demand proof before I give it a second thought, but when someone leaves me with a question, as scientists first did, and philosophers did later, that is when I am able to reshape my ideas. When someone is able to offer an argument which leaves a greater uncertainty in my beliefs, I am given these new questions to contemplate, and my new answers lead to a new, and usually 'better', stronger system of beliefs.

    It is because of this that I am forced to disagree with your final conclusion. While arguments like this haven't directly given me any answers, they gave me the questions I needed to ask myself to come closer to the truth I seek. As long as one approaches them with an open mind, no debate is truly pointless.
    Last edited by Heartless Angel; 03-10-2012 at 12:42 AM.
    For Our Lord Sheogorath, without Whom all Thought would be linear and all Feeling would be fleeting. Blessed are the Madmen, for they hold the keys to secret knowledge. Blessed are the Phobic, always wary of that which would do them harm. Blessed are the Obsessed, for their courses are clear. Blessed are the Addicts, may they quench the thirst that never ebbs. Blessed are the Murderous, for they have found beauty in the grotesque. Blessed are the Firelovers, for their hearts are always warm. Blessed are the Artists, for in their hands the impossible is made real. Blessed are the Musicians, for in their ears they hear the music of the soul. Blessed are the Sleepless, as they bask in wakeful dreaming. Blessed are the Paranoid, ever-watchful for our enemies. Blessed are the Visionaries, for their eyes see what might be. Blessed are the Painlovers, for in their suffering, we grow stronger. Blessed is the Madgod, who tricks us when we are foolish, punishes us when we are wrong, tortures us when we are unmindful, and loves us in our imperfection.





  20. #20
    Asking all the personal questions. God/Religion. Why? RamesesII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    I am a god, where ever the hell I please.
    Age
    38
    Posts
    1,143
    Blog Entries
    1

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    I want to quote something I heard today.

    Spirituality seeks truth and understanding.

    Religion seeks a reward in exchange for belief.

    I believe the fundamentals of spirituality is the same as the bases of most organised religions, but true base spirituality seeks truth and understanding in ones inner self without the need to worship or to have faith or belief in a deity only to have faith in your self, for example most Asiatic religions dare I say for lack of a better word help you understand and find virtues, proper ethics and moral judgment.

    Religion also has spirituality but at the mercy of a deity, it requires faith and belief in said deity to be able to find your spiritual path, it evokes control of the believer by way of rules and regulations and needs acceptance before one can find their path, if one is to busy following the path of these deities and seeking acceptance than what is overlooked is that we need to seek acceptance with ourselves first.

    I don't mean that every religious person out there is this way so don't go berating me for assuming that the masses are parallel to this.

    I also find it confusing to read that God has made us his children and yet he supposedly banished Adam and Eve from the Garden of Eden and then he brought about 40 days and nights torrential rain to punish us for our mistakes and now he turns around and says that every person even the murderers and rapists deserve forgiveness for our sins. This astounds me was there a pivotal moment in history (bible) that changed Gods will towards man is this where Jesus comes into it, was it his will to die for us to show god that we can be forgiven no matter what.
    I just find it hard that humans can put so much trust in someone so divine that makes mistakes and his mind can be changed at a whim.


    Various pagan religions believed that the sun was a god. They had a great big ball of fire in the sky to prove that their god existed. I'm sure you've seen it before.
    I sure hope your not making fun of mine and my peoples beliefs Mr Eastwood that would be a shame if Ra were to hear about this.
    Last edited by RamesesII; 03-07-2012 at 06:59 AM.
    A mouth of a perfectly happy man is filled with beer.
    --Ancient Egyptian Wisdom, 2200 B.C.



    Crao Porr Cock8, Go and get a Cock8 up ya.

    The finer details of a signature:


    CHE- "I pee sitting down after I have sex because for some reason after I have sex and I try to pee, it goes everywhere."
    Nuff said^


    My loving TFF Family:

    My beautiful go-go dancing Queen Aara
    My brother Meier Link, proudly supporting the World Wide Institute of Booze since 1982.
    My Spasmodic, spamtastic, spammer nephew Fate.
    My brother HUNK, he who wears the number 1 headband.
    My glowing Goddess of Egyptian thingy's, Unknown Entity.
    My Unique and unpredictable mother Kilala ^^.
    My little arcade freak brother nra4.
    My brother Captain of the Dragoon warriors, Mallick.
    My razzle, dazzle, razamatic, razphony brother Ralz
    My younger brother Ryu-Kentoshii Hirokima, the Legendary Samurai who Doesn't take "No" for an Answer.


    Literature:

    Recently read-
    Belgariad- David Eddings

    Currently Reading-
    The Tournament by Matthew Reilly


    Gaming:

    Currently PLaying

    -Minecraft
    - ASS Creed III





  21. #21

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Hey Ram-Ram(Rameses) after reading your post above on spirituality and religion I have a question. Forgive me for the potential ignorance but the ideas you propose of self spirituality and the enlightening of one self kinda self defeating? What I mean by this is that if one would limit the understanding and truth to only finding out your inner being/self/whatever than you are really only searching out self glorification and an elevation of onesself. Don't get me wrong that happens in religion also, but it isn't limited to that nor do I think that any self seekingness should be the or even a goal of a religion.

    I mean no matter how spirituality butters up the words that is the result right? It is completely self focussed and is very 'I' centered. 'If I can achieve this or if I live like this than I will be better than I am. I want to understand ME better.' I don't want to seem rude or anything but I mean leave it to humanity to make everything that we know and even the things we don't really understand like spirituality about us. I mean really at our core humanity is pretty self serving and self focussed anyway and we try very hard to keep things that way. So stemming from this we get all these can I say crooked views of spirituality and religion? Where the end goal is some sort of elevation of ourselves. Heck I mean even in Christian circles people claim that they have faith only because they don't want to go to hell. It's about them saving their own skin instead of a perspective shift.

    This is why I'm glad that within the branch of Christianity there is another side of the spectrum that focuses on God. Call it stupid or whatever but I actually went to school to study out the Bible and you can see that the Bible isn't about us but God. (In my circles God is Triune, three in his persons one in his essence.) The whole crux of the Bible is about him revealing his nature and plan so that he could restore the broken relationship we caused (Sin). I'm sure you all probably don't want me to delve into details and whatnot so I'll refrain unless requested later.

    HEY LISTEN!! Before anyone continues reading understand that the next bit is me answering Ram-Ram's later part of the post about if a Divine Entity did exist (God) why would he be changing his mind. So from the question it is assumed that such a Deity may exist. So keep that in mind before you jump all on this saying it is just a bunch of hogwash made up stuff and there is no God. I'm totally open to questions and such, and if requested I can drop verses to support my claims, however I'm pretty sure most of you don't think the Bible is even an inspired book by God, so I don't know if you'd even want verses...does that make sense? Oh...aaannnddd my reasons probably aren't perfect and if you notice flaws please point them out so I can learn from it. (Other than the idea that God doesn't exist so everything is invalid.) I'm not actually sure if I had to put all this but I kinda get the feeling some of us may get intense with the stupidity of people like me that live by faith. So my bad if I piss you off???

    So to answer the latter part of your post about God changing his mind on a whim. I would say that perhaps your reading of the text was a little smeared and that is fine. If I may try to give understanding to this I'd like to first point out that God is the perfect expression of all his attributes at all times, which might be hard for us to understand because we usually see things as kinda linear. For example we might see someone post something and say oh he did that out of anger or whatever. We only see one prevlenant characteristic at a moment even though we know that that person might not have even been angry and that that attribute isn't the only one to characterize their lives. Now if we do that with other humans than it must be possible to do that when reading about God who is suppose to be above our understanding to begin with. So what might solely appear as regret or doubt in the narrative of the Bible from God might not solely be that or that at all, same with expressions of wrath and anger.

    This all being said I would hold to one of God's attributes as being sovereign. The idea that in eternity past God already knew how everything was going to play out and therefore it plays out. Now before you call out hey I have free will. Free will is totally fine and I don't have a beef with it but because God knows everything he could use our free will in accordance to his plan to begin with. Anyways what I'm trying to get to is that despite the fact that God seemingly changes the plan or changes his mind in the narrative of the Bible doesn't mean he is. I'm not about to say that all life is a game to God just using it as an example but all competitive sports teams have game plans and within those plans are different avenues to take. In basketball for example you may play man to man or zone defense but your goal is still the same in stopping the opposing team from scoring and you wouldn't run the same play over and over again on offense you switch it up. So in God's grand plan of everything he does things differently at different times so that we might have a better understanding of what he is like. For example God cast out Adam and Eve and flooded the world to show that sin isn't something to be taken lightly. (I mean disobeying an infinite God has different consequences than disobeying your parents right?) EDIT: The difference between sports teams and God is that Teams have different plans based on if the opposing team does this or that (Plan A or Plan B) but since God already knew everything he only has a plan A and we from our perspective see things as they transition further in his plan. So in text when it says God regretted or changed his mind it really is only a transition in his plan and not a new one.

    As for Jesus paying/dying for mankind I would differ a bit with Sassy on this one. I would say that the debt incurred on mankind for sin was infinite (hence why mankind's punishment was eternity in hell because it would never be paid for fully) could only be paid for in full by something infinite in nature. Now without going on for another few paragraphs explaining it all. God himself could be the only payment to pay the debt as he is the only infinite being. Sacrfices in the old testment time was only a symbol of looking forward to the coming Messiah. (When God would take on flesh and who Christians believe is Jesus) would come and be the propitiation for sin.

    Anyways I think it is real hard to condense my beliefs because there is a lot to be understood in even the simple things in the narrative. I'm sure some of you definitely could have done without all the explaining and what not so again my apologies. I'm definitely open to debate and discussion though.
    Last edited by Imposter; 03-07-2012 at 03:28 PM.
    EBG


  22. #22
    ...means nothing to no way Furore's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    F*ckin' Australia!
    Age
    36
    Posts
    4,220

    Re: God/Religion. Why?

    Well, my beliefs have changed. Consider me an Agnostic Theist these days. Agnostic as I don't believe I'll ever know for sure if there is or isn't a God, Theist because I theorise a God or higher power exists. At the moment it's the only hypothesis that satisfactorily explains how things came into existence from nothing. But I don't feel all that strongly about my hypothesis, there's a great chance I'm wrong thanks to having insufficient data available.

    The only stances I agree with are Agnosticism; be it not willing to theorise, Theist or Atheist. Only because I'm going with a scientific approach and until the existence or inexistance of a God/Gods is disproven, the statements that God does or does not exist have no scientific basis. Oddly I still have that little instinctive twinge that something more exists, but who knows, it might just be a trick of the mind or something. I do know my faith was squished by seeing more and more useless suffering in the world. If there is an omnipotent being presiding over us, I'd feel naught but hatred for what has been unnecessarily wrought.

    I do hold some respect for all beliefs as for all I know those that hold them are correct, but no respect for those that won't do the same. It was intolerance in the past that caused friction, not religion itself. Too many irreligious are following in the footsteps of those they condemn for similar reasons. And don't get me started on door to door religion paddlers that don't take no for an answer or those types that say anyone not sharing their beliefs is going to Hell. Any place they're not going sounds like paradise to me.
    victoria aut mors

  23. #23
    Registered User God/Religion. Why? sayian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    north west ark
    Age
    41
    Posts
    203
    Blog Entries
    1
    8 years later... and sayian is no longer religious as of 5 years so far..for more reasons than there were reasons for me being religious my first 30 years on earth. its almost overwhelming the thought of actually trying to explain the totality of my personal growth. i literally just typed and deleted a paragraph trying. Basically, sometimes you get exposed to something that you cant deny. and when you are faced with it, you have to decide what kind of man you are. A coward who will dwindle back inside the comfort of ignorance, or a competent human being capable of intellectual growth. Some history wasnt taught(purposely). And, you know, when something so major in your life is in question, the pursuit of knowledge is like the pursuit of cake to a fat kid..
    ok keep on, its all shits n giggles until sombody giggles n shits....

  24. #24
    Mr. Person Taco-Calamitous's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2001
    Location
    Oregon
    Age
    41
    Posts
    5,705
    Blog Entries
    17
    I'm still religious, and I didn't bother to read what anyone else said 8 years ago, again. If I did the first time.

    I've been thru a lot in the last 8 years. There were times where I was more religious than not, and I found that I struggled more when I wasn't religious. Logic would say that it's in my head, but to be religious is illogical. You kinda have to be okay with that to be religious, and I am. But it's helped me get through life, whether it's in my head or not. It's what works for me. It's what's gotten me along on my journey. And everyone's journey is different.

    All I can say is "good luck" to the rest of y'all.

Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •