Thank you so much for saying this. As a dabbler in modern Chinese history myself, I also found this book utterly ridiculous. It's actually depressing, given the sources they had at their disposal that they managed to make such ludicrous conclusions.
As for me, I'm currently reading Master of the House by Oleg Khlevniuk which is an account of Stalin's relationship with the "small group of friends" that the Politburo staffed and who assisted in consolidating his power. I'm only about 40 pages in, but it's been pretty good so far. The author seems to have a level head and is drawing reasonable conclusions from the evidence he puts forward. Plus it's a great read.
Bookmarks