Of the new consoles, I have a PS3 and a Nintendo Wii.

My PS3 is still fairly new, and I don't have that many games for it (actually, I just have one, XD). I guess what prevented me from buying it at launch was the price. Looking back, though, I wish I would have bought one then instead of now. I could kick myself for not doing so.

I got my Nintendo Wii when it was first launched. Yep. I got caught up in the hype. I still like it, but it does seem that Nintendo is focusing more on the casual gamer market. If I still had my SNES, I wouldn't bother with the virtual console, but alas I do not. So more money goes to Nintendo for games that give me the nostalgia factor. There is one game that I can think of off the top of my head that I can't wait to get my hands on. Super Mario Galaxy 2. I loved the first one, and I hope this one will be just as great.

I have never had an Xbox or a 360, so I can't tell you my opinion about them.

I think you did a good comparison of the consoles, listing thier pros and thier cons. I really couldn't say who will emerge victorious in the end. I can speculate, but I won't.