Tool or A Perfect Circle?

[Sean]

Tool has a history of amazing albums, from their very first all the way up until now. Maynard is absolutely amazing in Tool.

A Perfect Circle's first album was absoltely amazing, Billy Howerdell really showed his shit there, but their 2nd album was only so-so, and their third and final wasn't even very good.

Tool is a way better band than A Perfect Circle, and easily rank amongst my top 5 bands ever, which Led Zeppelin, Red Hot Chili Peppers and Flogging Molly are a part of.

I mean, seriously... it should be no contest as to which of the bands Maynard sings for is better... and hell, Puscifer is better than APC by this point. Tool is vastly superior.


Edit: At above poster... Imagine was originally written by John ****ing Lennon, one of the greatest songwriters in history, no one in A Perfect Circle had anything to do with the writing of that song, and it's a sub-par to poor cover, at that.