Personally I quite liked the Hospital on the 2nd one the most, it was just so creepy and eerie looking, mind you the hospital on the 1st is good too and sad with the whole lisa thing.

And I do feel it is kind of short but I think that is partly because most games I play take at least 30 hours. I suppose I could go through them again but there is heaps of other games out there I need to complete. Either way I am up to the hotel so I may try and finish it tonight so I can dig into Silent Hill 3.