My fave songs from them vary. I once liked Blow Me Away. Diary of Jane, Until The End, So Cold, Hopeless etc.

But the song that I never ever get tired of listening to from them is What Lies Beneath. Mainly because it reminds me of two of my characters in my story. I also think the melody matches the lyrics perfectly as they are being sung in the song and I can really feel the emotion in them.

PS - Here We Are also gives me the similar feeling.