Quote Originally Posted by IcyJJ View Post
I would say go with FFVII. I say this because it seems like this is the one out of the two choices that you seem to keep coming back to. Replay value is important, but everyone judges this differently for each game. Since you can only pick one, pick the one that will make it worth the money.
I STRONGLY second this. VII is timeless. You say you beat it many times. hehe thats enough for me! As you can tell im not in anyway biased.