Results 1 to 5 of 5

Thread: Anyone here knows Serbian or Croatan? (question about Biskmatar)

  1. #1
    Delivering fresh D&D 'brews since 2005 Anyone here knows Serbian or Croatan? (question about Biskmatar) T.G. Oskar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Age
    38
    Posts
    1,597

    Anyone here knows Serbian or Croatan? (question about Biskmatar)

    After having a slight brainstorm (for something completely different, not FF Tactics but Dungeons & Dragons), I stumbled upon a very bizarre coincidence. This regards the etymology of the word, "Biskmatar" (aka, Llednar Twem's class in Final Fantasy Tactics Advance).

    While wandering around, I found that "kismat" is apparently a word loan from the Arab, meaning "fate or destiny" (more or less). However, the Serbo-Croatian language has a genitive of "kismata", which would suggest "person with fate/destiny". Then, I was pointed at the prefix "bez-", which means "without" or "-less" (as in, fateless or without destiny). This would suggest the word "bez kismata", which would roughly mean "person without destiny" or "fateless person".

    That...sounds a bit like Llednar's calling card, don't you think?

    Now, it may be a weird coincidence, but it may seem that they based the term "Biskmatar" from a degeneration of "bez kismata" (a rather weird one), specifically either "bekismata" or "bezkimata". Not saying they actually pulled that one off exactly as I said, but it may be a really interesting coincidence (or a weird hypothesis).

    However, I'm stumped at how the word "bez kismata" may degenerate, and this is where I need a native Serbian or Croatan speaker (or, if the prefix "bez-" and the word "kismat" mean the same in another language that one of you may be native to, suggest) to determine. It may be that, since there are two instances of an "s" based phoneme, that there may be a case of an allophone and perhaps a contraction of the word (much like the Japanese contracts compound words). Is there the chance that, through grammatical rules and perhaps a misunderstanding or two, the term "bez kismata" may have degenerated into "Biskmatar" (even through a Japanese misunderstanding)?

    If not, you're still welcome to answer whether this may be a really interesting coincidence, a word mutated into another, or a weird hypothesis built to create a coincidence.
    Delivering scathing wit as a Rogue using Sneak Attack.

    Pester me on the Giant in the Playground Forums if you really need me.

    The Final Boss Theorem:
    The size of the ultimate form of the final boss is inversely proportional to it's chances of actually beating your party. If you agree with this, please copy and paste this valuable piece of info on your sig. AND, if you're evil and villainous...never settle for a big form when a smaller form is more kickass...


    'Tis a shame I can only place names now...:
    Silver, Omnitense, Govinda, Aerif, Meier Link,
    (whatever is the name of) The Stig, Grizzly, Fishie,
    Craven, Spiral Architect, Flash AND Froggie.

    Spaces still available. Join today!!


    Nomu-baka, this is FAR from over...:

  2. #2
    Che
    Guest

    Re: Anyone here knows Serbian or Croatan? (question about Biskmatar)

    I don't know Serbian or Croat(i)an, but I am just coming in here to nitpick and say I hate it when people say "Anyone here knows ______?"

    No, not anyone here knows. Only certain people here know. So you ask "does anyone here know?" I love you TG, this is just one of my pet peeves!

    Also, I wouldn't be surprised at all by this coincidence. Square loves putting different kinds of mythology and stuff in their games.

  3. #3
    attempting to bribe the Mayor of Lambeth Anyone here knows Serbian or Croatan? (question about Biskmatar) Xanatos's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Bosnia and Herzegovina
    Age
    35
    Posts
    2,611

    Re: Anyone here knows Serbian or Croatan? (question about Biskmatar)

    First of all there's no such thing as Serbo-Croatian language, not anymore that is. That language only existed in former Yugoslavia and it's was a mixture of Croatian and Serbian who sound alike but grammatically are completely different. I'm a native Croatian and I would gladly help but honestly this is the first time I've heard of a word "kismata", I even asked my parents and one of my Serbian colleges, apparently they don't have a clue. There's a high chance that word kismata is still used in Bosnian language, a language that's almost same as Serbian and Croatian, well it's more a mixture of both, as still incomplete language they use a lot of loan words especially Arabian and Turkish.

    Both Serbian and Croatian language have the same word for "fate/destiny" which is "sudbina", so I don't see a reason for even using such a word as "kismata". Also the word "bez" can't possibly mean "less", it only means "without".

    I hope I was of some help.
    Last edited by Xanatos; 03-16-2010 at 08:17 PM.

    Sig and Avy made by Unknown Entity

  4. #4
    Delivering fresh D&D 'brews since 2005 Anyone here knows Serbian or Croatan? (question about Biskmatar) T.G. Oskar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Age
    38
    Posts
    1,597

    Re: Anyone here knows Serbian or Croatan? (question about Biskmatar)

    Quote Originally Posted by Xanatos View Post
    First of all there's no such thing as Serbo-Croatian language, not anymore that is. That language only existed in former Yugoslavia and it's was a mixture of Croatian and Serbian who sound alike but grammatically are completely different.
    Thanks for clearing that out.

    I'm a native Croatian and I would gladly help but honestly this is the first time I've heard of a word "kismata", I even asked my parents and one of my Serbian colleges, apparently they don't have a clue. There's a high chance that word kismata is still used in Bosnian language, a language that's almost same as Serbian and Croatian, well it's more a mixture of both, as still incomplete language they use a lot of loan words especially Arabian and Turkish.

    Both Serbian and Croatian language have the same word for "fate/destiny" which is "sudbina", so I don't see a reason for even using such a word as "kismata".
    Hmm...not a loan word nor an archaism, then? Granted, I used a less-than-reliable resource (Wiktionary...yes, you can go and bash me on that, and I expect at least one person to do so), but the entries suggest that it has been used on the region (and it does state it is based on an Arabic word, so it's mostly a word loan). The "-a" at the end seems to denote a genitive word, as well.

    Also the word "bez" can't possibly mean "less", it only means "without".
    Is it currently used as a prefix, or is it used as an adverb? Or, was it once used as a prefix in any case, by any chance?

    Still, assuming the word "kismet/kismat" was used as an archaism, and assuming the grammatical rules haven't changed (and using "bez-" as a prefix, assuming again it was used correctly), is there a chance that both would degenerate into something sounding similar to "Biskmatar"? Again, this is assuming the word "kismat" was used as a word loan or archaism (or a combination between archaism and word loan, in case "sudbina" is a neologism).

    I hope I was of some help.
    Oh, certainly. Even if it ends on a coincidence used as an attempt to make sense of the term (such as 613 x 913 = 4213)...
    Delivering scathing wit as a Rogue using Sneak Attack.

    Pester me on the Giant in the Playground Forums if you really need me.

    The Final Boss Theorem:
    The size of the ultimate form of the final boss is inversely proportional to it's chances of actually beating your party. If you agree with this, please copy and paste this valuable piece of info on your sig. AND, if you're evil and villainous...never settle for a big form when a smaller form is more kickass...


    'Tis a shame I can only place names now...:
    Silver, Omnitense, Govinda, Aerif, Meier Link,
    (whatever is the name of) The Stig, Grizzly, Fishie,
    Craven, Spiral Architect, Flash AND Froggie.

    Spaces still available. Join today!!


    Nomu-baka, this is FAR from over...:

  5. #5
    attempting to bribe the Mayor of Lambeth Anyone here knows Serbian or Croatan? (question about Biskmatar) Xanatos's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Bosnia and Herzegovina
    Age
    35
    Posts
    2,611

    Re: Anyone here knows Serbian or Croatan? (question about Biskmatar)

    Quote Originally Posted by T.G. Oskar View Post
    Still, assuming the word "kismet/kismat" was used as an archaism, and assuming the grammatical rules haven't changed (and using "bez-" as a prefix, assuming again it was used correctly), is there a chance that both would degenerate into something sounding similar to "Bismarck"? Again, this is assuming the word "kismat" was used as a word loan or archaism (or a combination between archaism and word loan, in case "sudbina" is a neologism).
    Now where heading somewhere, you see adding or removing one letter from a word can change the meaning and the sound of the same word, but you already know that. The thing is that its not that serious in English as it's in Croatian, Bosnian, Slovenian, Macedonian or Serbian language. I never heard of "kismata" but I've heard of "kismet", it's often used in Bosnian language for religious purposes. I found out that it's basically a Turkish version of word "kismata" and it's used in Bosnian language due to the fact that they have a lot of loan words from Turkey and they're of the same religion.

    In some cases the word "bez" can merge with the other words creating a completely new word with completely new meaning, unfortunately not in our case. When we merge the word "bez" with any of the following words "kismet", "kismata", "kismat" we get a word that doesn't haven any meaning on all three languages nor does it sound anything like "Bismarck".To make sense of it the word "bez" must be separated from the word "kismet" so we would have "bez kismeta" which would mean "without the fate". I apologize if I haven't explained this clearly enough, grammar was never my stronger side. Oh and I also need to apologize as it seems the word "bez" can become the word "less" while combing with the adequately word.
    Last edited by Xanatos; 03-17-2010 at 08:29 AM.

    Sig and Avy made by Unknown Entity

Similar Threads

  1. Random Question #7
    By Tidus1872 in forum General Final Fantasy
    Replies: 15
    Last Post: 01-22-2011, 01:06 AM
  2. A serious question regarding the FFT culture
    By Jeordam in forum Cleft of Dimension
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 09-10-2009, 11:10 PM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •