Tournament of Heroes (A RP Tournament)

[Merlin]

The whole thing sounds rather vague and contradictory:

• Quests: Each team will have its own quest based off their characters? This makes no sense and is more work than it is worth. For starters, simply creating quests based off of sets of randomly-picked characters would become tedious rather quickly. Not only that, it adds a huge factor of error to the equation of winning. One can easily claim that the quest that they recieved was harder or poorly formed in comparison to that of the quests of other teams. If it is not the same quest for each team it is inherently flawed and unfair. You might be trying to make it more 'friendly' for each team perhaps, but in the end the possibility of inequality will override any benefit you attempted to achieve. It will turn into a competion of alleged favorites.
  
• Judging: One of the most obvious questions that is going to come up is how is this thing going to be judged? With each quest being different for each group, there is no set guideline on how it should be done. Is it based on post length, grammar, creativity(bias? ), originality(once again.. bias? ), etc?
  
• The end: I know this whole thing is based off a RPB Tourney, but does the end need to be an RPB Tourney? I mean really.. from the sounds of it, this is nothing more than a RPB Tourney wrapped up nicely with a RP exterior. In the end, your characters still have to duke it out for supremecy, which is not the core belief instilled in this forum.

I'm not trying to rain on your parade, I just think these things need to be cleared up. Although I find the idea noble, I'm not particularly keen on it being based upon the RPB Tourney frameset.