Edited Songs on CDs... Do they ruin the CD?

[Unknown Entity]

Firstly, this is debatable. Either you hate edited CDs, or you think they do good. Is it ok to be interested in peoples opinions? If people don't wanna post an opinion, fair enough - they don't have to.

Secondly, yes. I DO think this is intellectual discusion. There could be many reasons why people choose to by un/edited versions of the CD - dur to moral, religious, or rather simple reasons.

And Thirdly, I wouldn't download the unedited version over the internet, because there is something arty about having the CD - stuff you WOULDN'T get if you just clicked the mouse a few times over iTunes. So remember: just because you download your music, doesn't mean everyone else does, ok?

[Lucid]

Fair enough, but if you really wanted it to be a topic to debate about then you should have talked about the moral and religious standpoints in your opening post and discussed it a bit.

Right now it just sounds like a "Hey guys, do you like edited or unedited CDs?" kind of talk.