Your opinion on the above signature

[Josh_R]

no arguments there Loaf, best pic of em I could find at the time.

As for yours 9/10 love it...

[Ralz]

Its sized well enough. 9/10

[Dodie16]

ZOMG!! THOSE THREE ARE FLOATING IN PURPLENESS!!! HURRY AND GIVE THEM SOMETHING TO HOLD ON TO!!!



Hmm.... I think you need to add some more design elements to it so your characters don't look like they're in empty space. It looks a bit on the simple side. Also, I would change the text on your name. It takes away from the Birth by Sleep font a little bit, imo.

I didn't win the internet. Your signature lied to me, but I like how you got your TFF family organized now.

7/10

[Fate]

Animation fan, here! And I loved how you made the text transition like that in the spoiler box. (How did you find out that BB Code? =P) I also think that the little banner next to the animation (outside the spoiler boxes) works effectively. There are some very, very little white pixels on the robe, still, but that's just me being extremely picky; plus, it's only noticeable on a dark color, so you've nothing to be worried about. The link at the bottom changes a lot, too, and I enjoy seeing what it is each time. xD

10/10

[Josh_R]

8/10 only cause the image is very large, to large in fact for me.

[Noctis Lucis Caelum]

7.5/10 I like it.

[Meier Link]

Why not split the images into 2 seperate ones. Your stretches the preset table limitations for my desktop.

The first one, while nice, is very predictable and almost over played out here on TFF and at any FF forum.

As for the second one, I am not sure how to comment on it seeing I can only see about 2/3 or it. From what I can see is that it looks jumbled and random.

Sorry but over all I am not super impressed with your sig. Honestly it is kind of plain all around.

3.5/10

[Fate]

I use TFF Dark, and the red looks very good on it. I don't know how it looks on Light, but I don't use that, anyway, so I worry about it. I think the banner is great, and the text is all good, too. Though, I can't help but be a grammar freak and say that in the final quote, the word should be "than," not "than." =P Other than that...

9.5/10

[Darkdragoon]

K... It's... Great =)
But you've had better one's =)
I give it... A 9.5/10 =)

[Ralz]

Nothing's changed, so my same comments before.

7/10

[Fate]

I think the thing that troubles me most is the text. You have such a busy banner that the text gets in the way. Actually, with that said, I changed my mind. There are too many images that stand alone as the "main" render. That's why the text seems to block out one of those images. Plus it's a bit hard to read on top of layers that dark of a shade.

[Ralz]

It's... so... shiny... o_O

9/10. 1 point off because the text blends in too well with the light.

Still... so... shiny... O_o

[Unknown Entity]

I don't know if this is the same one Fate was talking about, but I actually quite like the text. I think however, it would have looked better with a black stroke around the whole banner, and maybe if you'd made the text bold and black too.

Other than that, the only thing I dislike is the boxiness, but everyone has their own style and so I won't dig that.

I'ma give you... 9/10.

[Josh_R]

I am huge Soul Cal fan so I must give you a 9/10, a 9 for it being Kira....

[Azuteor]

I like what you've done for Kisuke Urahara on your Gaia Avatar. The sig needs more Bleach awesomeness.

8.5/10

[Fate]

OMG, I'm a complete sucker for bright, shiny things in banners. I really like the circular rune thing in the background.

10/10

[Fate]

God, I have such a liking to those sorts of color-blending, especially the parts with the white. 8D Knowing you, did you draw that?

COLORS! <333 10,10

[Alther Primus]

9.5/10, nice!

[ViviMasterMage]

Meigumi did some good stuff there! Is it all drawn on Paint? Even so 10/10!

[ZantetsukeN]

I enjoy it very much. Nice and bright 10/10

[Ralz]

Kiiiiiiiiira........... 9/10

(I can't wait for this. )

[Azuteor]

OMG.

7/10

-3 for creepiness

[Treize]

I like it. The colors work really well together. I guess the only negative thing I can say is that the text kind of blends into the background, but it is still readable if you look at it long enough. 9/10

[SuperSabin]

Hey, thats pretty good! It deserves an 8/10.

[Chaos_Weapon]

7/10- Very Inspiring and creative, but I like pictures.

[Unknown Entity]

It's kinda small and to the left. But good enough for a 7/10.

[chrono]

Side bewb and really short shorts that look like they should be underwear...........best sig on these forums.

[Confession]

Basic. Quite basic.

But it is not too bad so i'll give ya 7 blueberries otay/

[Treize]

It isn't too bad. I really only have two problems with it. The first one is that there seems to be excess transparent space on the top of it. The second one is more of a personal preference, but I'm not too fond of the font either. Right now it is a 7/10, but if you change those two things, it would be an 8/10.

EDIT: Actually, now that I look at it again, it might be better if it was a little narrower as well. 650 pixels is pretty big.

[Dodie16]

Hahaha.... I just watched that movie a few days ago. I enjoyed it a lot.

As for your banner, I like how you picked up the color of the flowers (or maybe on the car?) to use for your name and for the border. It's a long banner, but I like the sizing of it. I do see a few jagged bits that could be smoothed off a bit where Ponyo's hair is rendered, but it's not a big deal. I also like that you put in the streaks of white to give it some more visual interest. That's a nice touch.

I give your banner a 10/10. Great job!

Awww... Treize beat me to it.

Anyway, for Treize's banner, I think the two characters are cute. I like that you went back to using the character you had when I first joined TFF. Not that the Miku girl wasn't cute or anything, this seems more "you" to me though. It's a nicely sized banner, and the characters are rendered well. The background is basic, but that's my style too.

I don't see anything that I would really change.

10/10.