This is a fantastic idea but I have one problem with one of the rules. Photoshop and editing software should be allowed as they are a way of perfecting and bringing out beauty in photos. They shouldnt be seen as a form of cheating but rather a way of perfecting an otherwise brilliant photograph. By denying the use of editing software you would deny the ability to slow people to adjust and focus on the things they want to stand out. A great photo can use editing software, a horrible photo can also utilize it, but you would be able to see it and therfor bad jobs wouldn't win. You can tell when someone has overexcited and it looks horrible, so it should it should be allowed.