Gotta say 7. Of course, I also hated 12 with a Passion. The ONLY thing 12 had on 7 was the graphics, and those are just a bonus, not a selling point for a game. I've played through 7 more times than I care to remeber. I have at least 2 memory cards full of 7 data. 12 however, it took me almsot a year just to force myself to play through it. The story was forgettable, as were the characters. And I loathe the combat system. And I think I deleted my completed 12 file to Replay Valkyrie Profile. I'd talk about replay value, but for me 12 barely had first play value.