If the thread was purely about the different groups on TFF, and what people thought about it, then it would be fine for GC.

Now, if we were to talk about the psychology of such things, and how these groups are formed, then yes, it would be ID worthy. I mean, with the way this thread was designed, it belongs in Gen Chat. It was originally about TFF groups and opinions. It derailed into something ID worthy, but is now just a pissing contest.

I think that major distinction between ID and Gen chat is not that ID is for the "good" questions, but rather for your target audiences. If you want a a legitimate debate about ideas and the like, with sound reasoning and (more often than not) factual evidence, you post in ID. ID can get heated and it's not for a lot of people; understandable. Example: Obama's Healthcare Plan.

If you want a more relaxed debate or just to get people's opinions on ideas, then you post in Gen Chat. Example: Are aliens real?

The alien thread is NOT ID material. Mods be slippin.