I used to like Evanesence for a while but I didn't really fancy their latest album all that much either. My favourite song by them has always been Tourniquet. And I remember seeing an interview with Amy-Lee and she wasn't how I expected her to be, so I wasn't a big fan of her personality after that, and she also seemed much more pop/hip-hop then her punk/goth image led me to believe, but then that was only one interview so I can't really judge her on that.